匿名
匿名 發問於 社會及文化語言 · 7 年 前

Which sentence is correct

1. I know to which class he belongs.

2. I know which class he belongs to.

Which of the above sentences is GRAMMATICALLY correct?

更新:

"I know the teacher of the class to which he belongs."

"I know the teacher of the class which he belongs to."

Are there errors in the above two sentences?

2 個解答

評分
  • 7 年 前
    最佳解答

    The question is:

    Which class does he belongs to?

    I know the answer, so I reply as:

    I know which class he belongs to.

    "which he belongs to" is a noun clause, or more precisely, an interrogative content clause. Unlike relative clause where you could put the preposition in front of the relative pronoun, there is only one way to express in the interrogative content clause.

    Example of relative clause.

    I know the teacher of the class to which he belongs.

    I know the teacher of the class which he belongs to.

    Therefore, only sentence (2) is grammatically correct.

    2012-08-26 12:46:54 補充:

    Correction: The question is: Which class does he belong to? (no "s" after belong)

  • 7 年 前

    If we stick to grammar only, both of them are correct.

    However, if we consider our habits of speaking, it is more common to use sentence 2.

    資料來源: me
還有問題嗎?立即提問即可得到解答。