offer and acceptance Case 2

Alan 是Sales 車

10月1日,Christine 來問

How much would you sell this car for?

Alan 話40000,同給咭片佢

10月2日,Christine 就寫信給Alan

話會用40000買佢的車

但是Alan 一直都唔知

到咗10月30日先發現這封信

之後Christine 就看Alan 咁遲都唔回覆,以為佢唔買

在10月29日,就買咗另外一架車

那架車有沒有買到給Christine?

Alan /Christine 有沒有Legal position?

有咩case 支持論點?

最好講英文/中文

因為話offer and acceptance 都有時間限制

一個月,會否離譜?

更新:

口頭上講就已經是

不一定要書面contract

2 個解答

評分
  • 1 十年前
    最愛解答

    Christine wrote a letter to Alan to buy a car on 2 Oct. Under the postal rules, once the letter is posted (with prepaid stamp and proper address), acceptance is complete even if the letter is lost in the post and never reaches the offeror. So Alan should sell his car to Christine. Christine accept Alan's offer on next day, this is reasonable.

    If the offer did not have any option (fixed period), there is no time limit has passed. it may be terminated after a reasonable length of time has passed. e.g. if the price of goods is fluctuating rapidly in a particular market, then a length of time may be only an hour or so.

    However, In this case, It is not practically for the real situation as we will use T/T or phone to accept the offer rather than using the letter.

  • 1 十年前

    case 這d 變數都幾多,所以唔sure希望寄信話個觀點給我

還有問題嗎?立即提問即可得到解答。